Family tax credits and the questions preparers often miss
Credits can swing a tax return by thousands of dollars, and they're also where small assumptions cause the biggest headaches. A taxpayer mentions their daughter pays her own rent, or their son earned a chunk of investment income, and the instinct is to drop the dependent and move on. Sometimes that instinct is right. Often, it isn't, because each credit carries its own definitions and the tests for one don't automatically carry over to the next.
Here's a closer look at the questions that keep coming up around the earned income tax credit (EIC), the child tax credit (CTC) and the American opportunity tax credit (AOTC).
The EIC doesn’t ask who paid the bills
The most common mix-up involves a full-time college student who works and supports themselves. Can a parent still claim that student for EIC purposes? Potentially, yes. The EIC relies on the qualifying-child definition without the dependency support test, so a full-time student under age 24 can still be a qualifying child if the relationship, residency, age and joint-return requirements are met [§32(c)(3)(A); §152(c)].
The same logic means a taxpayer can claim the EIC for a child without claiming that child as a dependent. Because the support test drops out, dependency isn't always a prerequisite, although the child still has to pass the EIC relationship, residency, age and joint-return tests. Students can sit on the other side of the return, too. Full-time enrollment doesn't, by itself, disqualify someone from claiming the EIC on their own return, provided they meet the earned income, filing status, residency, age and other requirements of §32.
Unearned income isn’t an automatic disqualifier
A child with $8,000 or more in unearned income tends to raise eyebrows, but the dollar amount alone doesn't settle dependency. Run the child through the qualifying-child rules as you normally would [§152(c)]. The income does raise a separate issue: the child may have their own filing requirement or a kiddie tax obligation under §1(g). Treat dependency and the child's own tax picture as two distinct questions so one answer doesn't quietly decide the other.
Can a couple claim the CTC if one spouse has an ITIN?
Married taxpayers filing jointly can claim the CTC when one spouse has a Social Security number (SSN) and the other has an individual taxpayer identification number (ITIN). On a joint return, one spouse must hold a qualifying work-authorized SSN, and the other may have an SSN or an ITIN issued by the return's due date. The children's side is stricter, because each qualifying child must have a qualifying SSN [§24(h)(7)].
How is the refundable child tax credit calculated?
The refundable portion, known as the additional child tax credit (ACTC), starts with a simple formula: (earned income - $2,500) x 15%. Taxpayers with three or more qualifying children get a second route and use the greater of that result or the excess of their Social Security taxes over their EIC. Either way, the figure stays subject to the lesser-of limitation in §24(d) and the per-child refundable cap. For 2025 and 2026, that cap is $1,700 per qualifying child, while the regular CTC maximum is $2,200 per qualifying child [§§24(d)(1), 24(h)(5), 24(h)(6)].
AOTC details worth a second look
Qualified expenses for the AOTC include tuition, required enrollment fees and course materials needed for the course. Those materials don't have to come from the school itself, so a required textbook bought online can still count [§25A(f)(1)].
Dependency carries more weight here than it does for the EIC. If another taxpayer claims the student as a dependent, the student can't claim the AOTC. The taxpayer who claims the student may take the credit, as long as every other requirement is satisfied [§25A(g)(3)].
Phaseouts, the four-year limit and new ID requirements
Higher-income families often ask whether a year above the phaseout range burns one of their four AOTC years. It doesn't. When modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) is at or above the complete phaseout level, no credit is allowed for that year, and a year without a claim doesn't use one of the four claimed years. The separate limit tied to the first four years of postsecondary education still applies, though [§25A(b)(2)(A) and (C); §25A(d)].
Documentation has tightened as well. For taxable years beginning after Dec. 31, 2025, the taxpayer or one spouse on a joint return must have a qualifying work-authorized SSN. A dependent student for whom an education credit is claimed must also have a qualifying SSN, and the educational institution's EIN is required for the AOTC [§25A(g)(1)]. Asking for the school's EIN at intake, instead of chasing it in April, can save a round of follow-up calls.
Read each credit on its own terms
The pattern running through these questions is simple: a conclusion that holds for dependency may not hold for the EIC, and a rule that frees up the EIC may block the AOTC. Before carrying an answer from one credit to the next, pause and confirm which test actually governs. Want more reps with scenarios like these before next filing season? NATP webinars and Virtual Tax Season Updates dig into credits and the other issues landing on your desk, and a free trial lets you explore NATP member benefits.